Wednesday, May 8, 2019

Review of Medium Partner Program: Should You Pay to Earn?

What is the Medium Partner Program?

Review of Medium Partner Program: Should You Pay to Earn?
Image by PixLoger from Pixabay, edited on PicMonkey


I joined the Medium blogging platform in 2016, before the beginning of the Medium Partner Program (MPP.) A blogging friend had said the platform was a good place to have a presence. I discovered it was a good place to keep some of my posts from sites that had died until I could post them elsewhere. So in 2016 old posts I'd republished were all I had on Medium, and only a few of them. I didn't post anything else because at the time there was no way for someone like me to earn money at Medium.

In February 2019, my HubPages friend Glenn Stok told me about the Medium Partner Program that now provides an opportunity for writers like me to earn money. But there's a catch.

It takes money to have that opportunity. One must pay $5.00 a month or $50 a year to join the Medium Partner Program. That link provides all the program details and everything else you need to know in order to join the MPP. Only you, though, can decide whether it's worth the money to get this opportunity.

Should You Join the Medium Partner Program?


I asked Glenn, "Is it worth the money to become a MPP member?" His answer convinced me to give it a try. No one gets any affiliate commission by recruiting members, so he had no reason to exaggerate his results and I don't think he would anyway. He wrote a comprehensive article on Medium and the Partner program so I see no reason to try to rehash it here. He did an excellent job. Here's the link to Glenn's article: How to Make Money Writing Articles Without Ads on Medium. I prefer to tell you my own opinions based on my results and the other opinions I found was I was surfing the web.

My Experience as a Medium Partner Program Member


February 2019


I joined the Medium Partner Program on February 5, 2019. At the time I had nine posts there left over from 2016. I put five of them behind the paywall. The other four did not meet the content guidelines for the program. The pay period ended on February 24, so my work was only behind the paywall for 19 days in February.

Here is a chart of my first payday on February 27, and the money did go into my account on time. Post titles are on left. Earnings for each post are on right. Red letters are for posts removed from dead or non-paying sites. Green letters show posts I removed from HubPages, revised, and reposted on Medium. Blue letters show the name of Medium publication where a post was accepted and now appears. You can see that not all my old posts made money, but some did. Articles published on Friday-Sunday of a week often don't start getting views counted until the next week. Pay weeks go from Monday - Sunday. Where there is no publication, it means I didn't submit to a publication or the publication didn't accept that article.

During this same period, with 44 featured hubs, I earned $5.10 on HubPages.


Review of Medium Partner Program: Should You Pay to Earn?

March, 2019

In March I revised and republished more of my old stories and added some new ones. Here are the results. Again, the blue script shows what publications accepted the articles. The red shows where the revised articles originally appeared if they weren't on the last February image. PP stands for Persona Paper. Bub stands for Bubblews. Some articles from either of those sites may have appeared on both and I can't always remember which only came from Bubblews. Green still represents hubs (HP) revised and moved here.

During this same period, with 44 featured hubs, I earned $9.27 on HubPages.

Review of Medium Partner Program: Should You Pay to Earn?

April 2019


I have not repeated the sources here, but I have included the publications that accepted my posts. I did not  repeat the publications for the articles that earned nothing this month. You can see that although I made more money this month, some of the articles that earned money last month earned nothing this month. Unlike sites like HubPages, an article may have a short earning life.

During this same period, with 44 featured hubs, I earned $12.45 on HubPages. (Note: I have not written anything new on HubPages for a long time and interact there rarely now, but I do publicize my Hubs on social media. )



Review of Medium Partner Program: Should You Pay to Earn?

Conclusions from My Results

Unpublished Posts Moved from Other Sites Can Earn On Medium

I currently have thirty posts on Medium. Twenty-six are behind the paywall. Four are not. Of those behind the paywall, only eleven were written just for Medium. "Starved for Attention," which made the most the first month, made nothing the next two months. It was previously on another site, revised, and moved to Medium. "Jason, I'll Always Love You" was picked up by a popular publication, P.S. I Love You, and earned only .18 in February. In March it was my highest earner. It still did well in April.

Articles Published by Publications Usually Get Seen by More People than Those Published Independently

In the second month, some of the articles were picked up by publications, some of which I didn't even submit. Articles that appear in popular publications with lots of subscribers are distributed more widely than those one self-publishes. However, inclusion in a publication does not guarantee more earnings.

Curated Articles Get Wide Distribution and Usually Earn the Most. 

My three curated articles have performed best for me so far. When you put your article behind the paywall you can also choose to have it sent to the curators for consideration. They pick which articles Medium itself will promote in its newsletters that go out to all Medium subscribers. Curation gives articles the best chance to be seen by lots of eyes. These are my curated articles so far.


Medium Earns More for Me Than HubPages on New Articles

On the other hand, older Hubs retain more earning power than older Medium posts. Working together Medium and HubPages give you the both of best worlds. Would I make more on HubPages if I kept submitting more hubs and interacting as much as I do on Medium? Possibly. The statistics I gave for HubPages above my earning charts are for my original account. My Squidoo transfer account makes almost nothing there, and it's those articles I plan to revise and transfer to Medium or somewhere else. 


Review of Medium Partner Program: Should You Pay to Earn?
Image by isuru prabath from Pixabay, edited in PicMonkey 


Medium Is a User Friendly Site for Readers and Writers

After a struggle with the quirks of the WordPress and even the Blogger editor, Medium's editor is simplicity itself. One can just concentrate on writing. It's the words and the images that are important. No quizzes, polls, videos, etc. are considered important post ingredients as they are on HubPages. The focus is on what you say. I  like not having to sell anything to make money. I would like to focus on stories and ideas as opposed to products. 

As a reader, I also like reading Medium posts because they're not full of affiliate links and ads. You can read all the way through a Medium article without encountering one pop-up asking you to subscribe to a newsletter. Readers can concentrate on content. I think many people subscribe for that reason. 

There is a wealth of interesting content on Medium. Many Medium members are not writers, but readers. They are not part of the Medium Partner Program, but they are the ones who read our work and help us earn for our writing. 


What I Like Best About the Medium Partner Program


Medium allows me as much freedom as I want. I can write in any genre. I can apply to a publication or not. I can write on any subject, though some subjects won't earn as much as others. As long as I follow the guidelines for the Medium Partner Program, I can put any article I want to behind the paywall. Of course, that doesn't mean it will earn anything. 

Medium treats me like an adult. It lets me take responsibility for my own work. I can publish it independently without submitting it to a publication editor and waiting for approval and publication. That means I am also free to publish inferior work that is less likely to earn than more polished work.

Proofreading is my responsibility alone. Publications want quality, so they do have editors to make sure what they publish is worth reading and is free of errors. But they don't correct it for you. They send it back to you or reject it outright. If a publication rejects your work, you are still free to publish it yourself. 

For an article to earn, other Medium subscribers need to see it, read it, and interact with it. Curated articles are most likely to get a kick start leading to more views on Medium. Articles in publications also get help from a newsletter the publication sends to its members listing new articles. 

Views from promotional links on social media don't usually bring in paid views. Traffic from Twitter automatically gets past the paywall for free. Most writers usually post a friend link when they post to social media so that readers can bypass the paywall if people click through. That means a well-promoted post with lots of traffic may not earn much if the readers aren't Medium members. 

Writers for publications often have their own Facebook groups for promotion. Koinonia is one of my favorite publications for Christian writers and it has an active Facebook Group. I know of three other active Facebook groups that are open to any Medium writers for discussion and threads for sharing posts. All these promotion opportunities and the support from other members is very helpful to new Medium writers. 

Most Medium publications encourage personal articles. They like authors to share what they've learned about  relationships, family life, work, mental health, business, and a number of other topics. Unlike HubPages, they prefer articles written in the first person rather than the third person, unless they deal with science or other very objective subject matter. Articles that speak directly to readers with a personal voice seem to do best.

Medium makes it easy to build your own following. You can even start your own publication on Medium if you don't find another that suits you or you want to keep your work in one place to make it more accessible to your followers.




The Downside of the Medium Partner Program


You are making an investment of five dollars a month or fifty dollars a year. There is no guarantee you will earn it back within those time frames. I'm on my eleventh week. If my earnings hold to their current pattern I will have covered my first year's membership by the end of the twelfth week and the rest will be profit. There is no guarantee that will happen. But I've never yet earned back with ads and affiliate links what it cost me to self-host a WordPress blog, and that was a far larger investment. My membership also allows me unlimited reading behind the paywall, and that's been worth the fee by itself.

You cannot include affiliate links or a call to action in a post that goes behind the paywall. You can, however link to another Medium post you have not put behind the paywall. In that post you may have an affiliate link or a call to action. You just need to make sure it's not interpreted as writing a post behind the paywall that only exists to point to another site.

If your posts aren't curated or promoted by a publication, they may not get much traffic. I have four posts that have received no fans or applause. Three were first published somewhere else between 2014 and 2016 and their original publishing dates followed them. If I publish older posts again, I will not use the importer which retains the original date. I will unpublish from the first site and revise for Medium.

The other unloved post was a rant published just for Medium. A few people read it, but no one liked it enough to applaud. That happens. I'm wondering if I should tweak the title and republish it.

If my current results on Medium hold up until the end of the year and my earnings keep growing, I will join again next year. A full year will help me see whether this is the direction I should go. But even if it's a wonderful year and I earn even more than I expect, there is that final downside. Medium can change the terms of the MPP any time they choose. They could stop paying. They could even close the site, though I think that's unlikely.

I have written the obituaries for many sites. One was What Can We Learn from the Fall of Bubblews? It was first published when Bubblews was still alive -- to answer questions about the living site. Some of the original predictions remain intact, but the post itself has been updated many times as things changed. I updated it once again and changed the title when when Bubblews finally died. Many of us who used to rely on Squidoo for income were crushed when it died.

We can never depend on any site we don't own for future income. It's always better to own your own site if you can make a profit. Meanwhile, as we build an audience, we can introduce ourselves to new readers on sites like Medium and  HubPages.

Possibly the biggest downside to writing for Medium is that you may be tempted to to neglect your own blogs. I have. I've also neglected other sites like HubPages. It's always a good plan to back up one's work on all sites, just in case, and not to put all one's eggs in one basket.





Note: The author may receive a commission from purchases made using links found in this article. “As an Amazon Associate I (we) earn from qualifying purchases.”


FOLLOW US ON:

16 comments:

  1. Interesting, Barb. I wish you much success with this!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank You. I'm happy. It's payday and I've now earned back all of my $50 membership and more by the end of this eleventh week of my membership. The rest is all profit.

      Delete
  2. I really appreciate your honest evaluation of Medium Partner Program. Since so many writing platforms have come and gone in the last few years, I have been extremely hesitate to even give them a try, must less pay to publish. It is extremely difficult to keep fingers in too many pies. Since Squidoo went out of business, I have focused on my own independent sites. I detest spending a lot of time somewhere only to see it shutdown (and lose all of my articles Google ranking even if I do move them elsewhere) I can see real value though in a place like Medium where you could get your "brand" out there. Once questions, and I do apologize if you already answered it above and I missed it, can you link to other articles on other sites on your articles behind the paywall? (I know you said you could link to other Medium articles, but question if you could link to other sites)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You can link to other sites as long as you don't write the article for that sole purpose -- to direct readers somewhere else, and as long as the links aren't affiliate links. You just have to do it tastefully and appropriately, as you would on Hubpages. In fact, one of my best Medium articles, "Jason I'll Always Love you" has a link to one of my hubs in it. It has now earned $16 since it was published February 21. It was curated under "Family" and appears in the "P.S. I Love You" publication. I would not suggest linking to lots of outside sources in one article, but if you have a link that enhances your article and gives more details you can use it on articles behind the paywall. You would not want to write articles to promote products or specific websites and then link to them. Once you join and begin to read other paid articles you will see how others approach this and which publications you might most want to submit to. One thing that might do well for you would be an article about your experience grieving the loss of a much-loved pet. If it shows a life lesson or what got you through it near the end of the article, it might get accepted by the Ascent publication. If it had a Christian slant it would fit in Koinonia. Or you can just self-publish. As to external links, each publication also has its own guidelines. Hope that helps.

      Delete
  3. You always are up-to-date on the latest publishing sites, Barbara, and I appreciate your evaluation of the Medium Partner Program. Many times new programs come along I am not aware of or do not understand, so having one like this explained is very helpful. Thank you for your review.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. LOL, so many new sites pop up I'm not even aware of some of them. I've been on Medium since 2016 and it was four years old then. It's only recently they started offering writers like us the opportunity to earn money there.

      Delete
  4. I have a few questions. What is a paywall? How exactly do our articles earn money, is it by number of views or some other means? Who do you submit your articles to? Are they submitted to Medium in general or does Medium have sub publications (like HubPages?) that you can choose who you want to submit your article to? I am unsure as to the structure of Medium, it sounds much like HubPages. Thanks Barbara!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When you publish as a MPP member, you chose whether you want anyone to be able to read your article for free (and you won't earn money for it,) or you chose to put it into a restricted part of the site, behind the paywall. Medium allows non-members to read three articles a month free and then if you try to read a fourth you need to pay to join or subscribe to the site. Many well-known newspapers also do this.

      To make sure family and friends can read your work, there is a friend link available for each article. you can use it on social media or to share with friends through other means. It will allow those who use that link to read that one article free even though it's behind the paywall. Interaction by non-members will not count toward your pay, but if members use those links, their interaction will still count. Links posted to Twitter will also allow anyone who follows them to read an article behind the paywall. But only interaction by paying members will increase your earnings.

      To submit your articles on your own go to the three dots to the right of the "Ready to Publish" button. You can submit to a publication. Each publication has its own guidelines and instructions. Once you are accepted as a writer by a pub, when you click the three dots at the top of the editing page to submit you will see "add to publication" in the dropdown list. If you click it you will see a list of all the publications that have accepted you as a writer and you click on one of them. When you finish all you need to do under those three dots, including checking your title, subtile, and tags, you click on "Ready to Publish" to the left of them. If you have not yet been accepted yet to a pub, follow that publication's instructions on how to submit. You usually have to send an email to an editor with the link to your draft (also obtained from the list under the three dots) and your profile, and whatever else the instructions ask for.

      The pubs are comparable to HubPages sub publications. You submit and the pub accepts or rejects. If they reject you can submit to a different pub or publish on your own. Sometimes a pub you haven't submitted to will suddenly appear on your list of pubs and you will discover they have included your article. I've had that happen. (That also has happened on HubPages.) I guess there are many similarities between the two sites. HubPages may be a better source of residual income, and new articles may earn faster on Medium and then get little action after the first month.

      Delete
  5. Barbara, I've been trying to get an understanding of Medium and your article here helps, as well as the links, but I'm still having trouble finding what I want to read on the Medium site. I'm interested in writing travel articles since I'm soon going to be traveling... but can't find them on Medium. I'd be interested in how other travel writers are doing there. And I guess it is like HubPages ... you have to try to get your articles "curated" for a "publication" . . . so, where is there a list of those publications? I'd like to sign up for the program and commit to posting 10 articles to see how they do on the site, but I'm a little frustrated by not being able to find things... and if I'm not finding them, does anybody?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Linda, somehow my reply to you landed under Olivia's comment and, perhaps, the reply to her I'm about to make.

      Delete
  6. Wow Barbara, this is really interesting. I always look for someone I know personally when looking at sites to write on for profit. I have been hoodwinked more than once by other platforms that promise all kinds of payouts and then fail to deliver.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've tried to tell as much of the truth as I know. So far this site is working very well for me, but there is never a guarantee with any site that future results will be the same. I think a year is a good test period. I'm taking the attitude I did when I started writing for Bubblews -- use it for as long as it works for me. Today's payday on Medium put me in the black after only eleven weeks of joining the MPP. I really love being able to earn for writing about things that are important to me instead of always having to try to sell something in order to make money.

      Delete
  7. That part is hard. You could ask about it on the Medium Mastery Facebook list. You could search Smedian's list of publications. I think you'd get much more action posting about Protective Services abuses you've seen, and making it personal. I don't see too many travel articles on Medium. Of course, you could start your own publication. Medium readers seem to be most interested in personal stories, relationships, family, writing and publishing, fitness, food, etc. Check the guidelines for The Ascent, the Writing Cooperative, P.S. I Love You, Koinonia and others you come across when you are reading. If you like an article and you can picture yourself writing something on a similar subject, go to the end of that article and see if it's in a publication. Follow the person. Click on the publication and follow it to see if it appears to be one you'd like to submit to. But self-publish a couple of things first so you will have something to show editors who come check your profile. If you don't know where to start, go to Koinonia. You would be a good fit there. there are many articles worth reading. Most of the authors you like there will also have been published on other publications you can check out. Just surf the site and keep reading, clapping, and commenting. Make friends. If I like something, I check the author's profile for more I might like to read. I bookmark the piece at the end by the clapping hands. I then read and interact with things I've bookmarked later when I'm too tired to write. Before long you will find plenty to read. Sign up for the Medium Digest where you can pick your topics. Join the Medium Mastery Facebook group to find things to read.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The reply above was for Linda Jo Martin, whose comment is above Olivia's, and somehow landed in the wrong place.

      Delete
  8. Barbra, thank-you so much for sharing this. It is something any writer blogger is going to at least want to look into.

    ReplyDelete
  9. One needs to consider what one wants to write about and determine if an audience exists on Medium for that. One way to determine that would be to join for a month, read widely in your areas of interest to see if others there share your interests. Write a few posts during that time, put them behind the paywall, and then see if they get read. I'd give it at least three months before quitting for lack income. I never would have joined had I not known that the site has been around longer than most I've joined and is still there. Of course, as with other sites, networking within the site membership is important in getting a reading audience.

    ReplyDelete



The Review This Contributors

Cynthia SylvestermouseCynthia SylvestermouseDawn Rae BDawn Rae BMary Beth - mbgphotoMary Beth - mbgphotoBrite-IdeasBrite-IdeasBev OwensBev OwensWednesday ElfWednesday ElfBarbRadBarbRadOlivia MorrisOlivia MorrisRenaissanceWoman2010Renaissance
Woman2010
Lou16Lou16The Savvy AgeThe Savvy AgeTreasures by BrendaTreasures by BrendaMargaret SchindelMargaret SchindelBuckHawkBuckHawkDecoratingforEventsDecorating
forEvents
Heather426Heather426Coletta TeskeColetta TeskeMissMerFaeryMissMerFaeryMickie_GMickie_G

 

Review This is Dedicated to the Memory of Our Beloved Friend and Fellow Contributor
We may be apart, but You Are Not Forgotten

Susan DeppnerSusan Deppner

“As an Amazon Associate I (we) earn from purchases.” Disclosure Statement

X